Moontide Isle: Tampa Bay’s Iconic Island Home Returns to Market After Hurricane Damage
Iconic Moontide Isle Back on the Market After Hurricane Milton’s Wrath
New Port Richey, FL – Nestled on its own tiny island in the Pithlachascotee River, Tampa Bay’s beloved “Moontide Isle” is once again making headlines as it returns to the market following significant damage from Hurricane Milton last month. This unique property, located at 5329 Richey Dr., is a piece of local history that has weathered many storms—both literal and metaphorical.
Originally built in 1946 by a well-traveled cartographer, Moontide Isle is renowned for its artistic details and whimsical charm. The home features two bedrooms, two bathrooms, three fireplaces, and even a moat crossed by a wooden footbridge, offering a full-circle waterfront view that has captivated residents and visitors alike.
The estate is being sold as a three-parcel sale, which includes an adjacent two-bedroom, one-bathroom guest cottage complete with a pool and a covered boat lift, as well as an additional lot featuring a two-car garage.
In a nostalgic nod to its storied past, a 2005 article from the St. Petersburg Times dubbed Moontide “one of the most romantic houses ever built.” Former owners Jill and Rocky Marcus recounted their own journey of restoration, noting that the house came with its own sandbags when they purchased it in 2002. “It was in pretty bad shape,” Jill remarked, a sentiment that resonates once again as the home faces the aftermath of Hurricane Milton.
Currently, the property is being marketed as a “fixer-upper or a teardown,” with the listing highlighting the extensive damage incurred from floodwaters. Photos reveal a home that has been largely gutted, presenting a blank canvas for potential buyers with a vision for restoration.
Property records indicate that two parcels on the island last sold in 2021 for a combined $850,000. The asking price in December was $899,999, but the listing ultimately sold in March for $760,000, reflecting the ongoing challenges in the real estate market.
As Moontide Isle seeks a new owner, it stands as a testament to the resilience of both the property and the community it represents. Every house has a story, and Moontide’s narrative continues to unfold.
For those interested in this unique opportunity, the listing is available for viewing on Zillow.
Creative Loafing Tampa Bay remains committed to showcasing the rich tapestry of Tampa Bay’s historic homes. If you know of a unique Florida property that deserves attention, reach out to us at cwolf@cltampa.com.